Second grader Alden Kiser bent the black microphone way, way down, its red foam top moving toward his mouth.
Alden got on his tiptoes and leaned in, the top of his head barely visible over the Sahuaro High School auditorium lectern.
The five Tucson Unified School District Governing Board members and Superintendent Gabriel Trujillo peered down at Alden from the stage.
Then, the Collier Elementary student spoke, his voice clear and strong:
“I love learning outside and exploring because it is full of adventure. You get to discover things you might have noticed before, might have never noticed before,” he said. “In science last week we went on a scavenger walk and looked for things around us. We got to draw something we wondered about and write a question.”
Alden was one of the more than 200 in attendance at Tuesday night’s public hearing where the board heard three-minute comments from about 60 members of the community on proposed school closures. More than 70 people registered to speak and 18 letters were submitted into the record at the nearly five-hour meeting.
TUSD is recommending closing or merging 14 schools because of declining enrollment that has led to a loss of about $29 million in available state funding over the last five years, Superintendent Gabriel Trujillo said this fall. District officials point to lower Pima County birth rates and families using Empowerment Scholarship Accounts as the primary causes for right-sizing Southern Arizona’s largest school district.
The district proposes six schools be merged or closed for the 2027-28 school year:
• Hudlow Elementary closing and merging into Sewell Elementary
• Cragin Elementary closing and merging into Blenman Elementary
• Collier Elementary closing and merging into Bloom Elementary
In 2028-29:
• Magee Middle School closing and merging into Sabino High School
• Steele Elementary closing and merging into Booth-Fickett K-8.
• Secrist Middle School closing and merging into Santa Rita High School
• Cavett Elementary merging into Utterback Middle School
Nearly all those schools were represented at Tuesday night’s public hearing. But the parent-teacher organizations at Collier and Cragin Elementary Schools stood out in their coordinated turquoise T-shirts. Their hand-made signs were prohibited in the Sahuaro auditorium, which seats about 1,200. But some silver sparkly pompoms peeked out from backpacks and purses.
Proposed vote
What: TUSD board vote on realignment
When: Dec. 8, 5:30 p.m.
Where: Palo Verde High School, 1302 S. Avenida Vega
Alden was one of more than two dozen from Collier who spoke to board members about the official parent-led proposal to turn it into a K-8 outdoor learning school with an environmental focus.
“We could go on hikes to Bear Canyon, Sabino Dam, and Saguaro National Park. We could even visit Mount Lemmon to learn about sky islands and how different plants and animals live in different places,” he said. “We could learn about animals, art, music, math, poetry, and nature all together. I think being outside is so much fun. It’s an adventure. You learn so much at the same time. I want to do these things with my friends and discover even more things we haven’t thought of yet. I really like Collier. I don’t want it to close. Please give us the opportunity to turn Collier into a Sonoran Desert learning school.”
Collier, a K-6 school on the far east side, is the smallest of the schools proposed for closure and TUSD is recommending it merge with Bloom Elementary about four miles away. Collier has 93 students and is at 38% capacity, according to TUSD data. It is the only school on the realignment list with a formal proposal for the district to consider.

Alden’s final words were muted by the “WHOHOOOOOOOO!” from the crowd. Snaps and loud claps followed during the only standing ovation of the hearing. He walked away from the mic as dozens more people followed over the next three hours.
Tuesday night’s hearing centered on right-sizing the district, an idea Trujillo began seriously floating a year ago.
Last spring, the board laid out a timeline: Four community information sessions dotted September and October and schools recommended for closure or consolidation were named over the last two weeks of October and the first few days of November.
Tuesday’s community voices raised two key questions for the board:
• Could waiting for a Democratically-led state Legislature, which begins work in 2027, mean anything different for public school budgets and enrollment?
• Does closing schools really save money and possibly maintain enrollment, as the district says, because some families note they will transfer outside TUSD when their schools close, rather than make the transition to the receiving school?
Across the U.S., a total of 1,156 schools closed during the last academic year, the highest number since the pandemic, according to an analysis of federal data by Big Local News at Stanford University.

Tuesday’s 4.5-hour hearing was dedicated to the passionate voices speaking to their experience. They included parents, grandparents and caregivers; business and property owners; teachers, counselors; alumni and current students. Some sound bites from the public hearing:
“I ask you to please give Cragin a chance to continue to grow because 14 years ago a little girl walked through those preschool doors holding someone’s hand. Now, I am a future role model. Tonight that little girl is standing before you dreaming of becoming a teacher because of the people who once and still believe in me. Please don’t take away the opportunity for another child to have that same start.”
— Isabella Maldonado, Former Cragin Elementary student and current Catalina High senior
“Showing up to a job you love knowing the relationships you’ve built over years could be erased is devastating. Not only does closing schools disrupt students’ structure, it plays right into the billionaire-led war on public education. Following the Nov. 3 election, Arizona is shifting from leadership that have prioritized vouchers toward an administration with different goals for public education. This changing political landscape gives reason to believe the voucher program, which is responsible for much of TUSD’s declining enrollment, is on its way out. Parents, staff, community members, and students have spoken out and even offered solutions, like examining the increased costs going toward district admin which reflects a priority of district admin over student well-being. Do you want to be known as the district that puts district admin’s well being over students? It’s time you listen to us. Stop the closures!”
— Nicole Janzen, school counselor C.E. Rose K-8
“I’m against the closure of Hudlow. I along with my colleagues, students, families, and homeowners have a mixture of feelings from being sad, angry, worried, confused. We were told that Hudlow is moving to Sewell. Told. Not, say, ‘Let’s have a conversation about this.’ At this point, we are asking to have more time. Give us more time. Why are we not letting the stakeholders talk to each other and talk to the board, talk to who needs to know about the difference between Sewell and Hudlow? Why can’t Sewell come to Hudlow? We welcome them.”
— Trish Miller, Hudlow Elementary Kindergarten teacher
“I really, really believe this decision of what we do as a community moving forward would be your legacy. It will be what people will say about TUSD. And if we can figure out how to come together as a community and address the needs and figure stuff out and do it well and fix the schools, not just save money, but fix the schools, the legacy, the story, the narrative will be a beautiful one that can change Tucson for decades.”
— Kevin Phillips, Secrist Middle School teacher
“With the first truly pro-public education state government in decades, we have the opportunity we’ve all hoped and canvassed for. TUSD stands to receive the funds we’ve been criminally denied: $141M in capital funding, the potential for full day kinder funding, changing funding formulas for ExEd categories and other items — structural and systemic changes that will be extremely difficult for the opposition to undo in years to come. A process to close schools that started under an outgoing political landscape needs to be reconsidered under new, favorable conditions. Closing schools risks losing families, trust, and the very enrollment we wish to capture and grow. Let’s win the schools our students deserve.”
— Jim Byrne, President, Tucson Teachers Association
“I would prefer to ask questions. That way, the public can have some of their questions answered.”
— TUSD governing board member Jennifer Eckstrom after more than three hours of public testimony and a discussion centered on whether to read the 18 submitted letters into the record
“My name is Vanessa and I’m a parent of a second grader at Steele Elementary. She is in the K-3 second grade class of Miss Ball. My daughter has Down syndrome and autism. She is also G-tube fed and requires close observation. I chose Steele because of the close-knit family. They made us feel welcome from day one of Macie’s first day of school. The small class size is perfect for her since she gets the attention she needs. She also is overstimulated with too many people. Her teacher and all the aides in class and all the school staff are wonderful and they are all very available to our needs. I would like for you to reconsider on closing Steele as it will affect many families in the community. ”
—Steele Elementary parent Vanessa Estrada via letter
“The schedule shows that you plan on keeping the kids separated, but frankly you can’t be in every bathroom, every locker room, every classroom all the time. I didn’t see anything where you showed how supervision is going to work during the after school programs and extracurricular activities like clubs and sports. And so I think you haven’t considered it or just don’t have a solution for that. … Tonight I’ve heard an overwhelming ‘no’ of protest. We had a very eloquent second grader come here and tell us that this isn’t OK because even a child can see how ridiculous this proposal is.”
— Malcolm Burtley, TUSD dad, whose daughter is headed to Magee Middle School in 2027
“Closing schools and consolidations isn’t the only thing. But we’ve got to be smart about it. … If we close Collier, we close off the lifeline to Sabino Canyon. We might as well give that land to Tanque Verde.”
— TUSD board member Val Romero on closing east-side TUSD schools could give enrollment to other school districts


